Birth planning in Melbourne: your options, the risks and a plan that fits you

Reviewed by Dr Fiona Cowell, MBBS (Hons), MRepMed, FRANZCOG. Last reviewed: 10 November 2026.

Birth planning is a conversation about how you would like to give birth, what the options and risks are, and how your own wishes and the health of your pregnancy shape the best plan for you. Dr Fiona Cowell, a Melbourne obstetrician, is committed to informing women about all the options available and giving them choice to have the birth they want. She discusses the benefits and risks of each option and personalises her advice to your preferences and to the risks of your pregnancy.

How Dr Cowell approaches birth planning

  • She explains the options for your birth, and the benefits and risks of each, in plain language

  • She asks what matters most to you, including how you hope to give birth, your pain relief preferences and any worries from a past birth

  • She factors in the risks of your own pregnancy, such as a medical condition, a previous caesarean, twins or a complication in this pregnancy

  • She gives you a clear recommendation, and the decision stays yours

Your plan is not fixed. It can change as your pregnancy and labour progress, and you can talk through it again at any visit.

Your options

  • Vaginal birth, with or without pain relief

  • Induction of labour, to start labour rather than waiting for it to begin on its own, which may be offered because of a health condition, waters breaking without labour starting, or other concerns

  • Assisted birth using forceps or a vacuum to help your baby move down the birth canal

  • Planned caesarean, scheduled for medical reasons or after discussion of your circumstances and preferences

  • Emergency caesarean, which may be needed if labour stalls, your baby shows signs of distress, or a complication arises

Questions worth asking about any intervention

  • Why is this recommended for me?

  • What are the risks of having it?

  • What are the risks of not having it?

  • What are the risks of waiting and seeing?

  • Are there other options?

Interventions during labour go ahead with your informed consent, and you are encouraged to ask questions at each step.

If you have had a caesarean before

After one uncomplicated caesarean, you can usually choose between a planned repeat caesarean and a trial of labour for a vaginal birth after caesarean (VBAC). The Royal Women’s Hospital reports that about 60 to 80 per cent of women attempting VBAC give birth vaginally, rising to about 87 to 91 per cent if they have also had a vaginal birth before. The main risk specific to VBAC is rupture of the scar, which occurs in about 4 to 5 in every 1,000 women attempting it.

A planned repeat caesarean has its own surgical risks, and complications increase with each additional caesarean. Which is best for you depends on the reason for your first caesarean, how you felt about it, your health and what matters most to you.

If your pregnancy is higher risk

Birth planning matters most when there are extra risks, such as a medical condition or twins. In these cases, Dr Cowell will explain how the risks change the options, the timing of birth, and the hospital and support you may need.

Where you give birth

Dr Cowell delivers babies at St Vincent’s Private Hospital Fitzroy and Epworth Freemasons. You can discuss which one suits you, and how your preferences can be supported there.

Writing down your preferences

Some women find it helpful to write a short list of birth preferences to share with the team who will care for you in labour, including any interventions you would like to avoid. It is a guide for the conversation, not a contract, and the safety of you and your baby always comes first.

Frequently asked questions

Can I plan my birth with Dr Fiona Cowell?

Yes. Dr Fiona Cowell is committed to informing women about all the options available and giving them choice to have the birth they want. She discusses the risks and benefits of each option and personalises advice to your preferences and the risks of your pregnancy.

What if my birth does not go to plan?

Birth plans can change, because labour and pregnancy do not always go as expected. Dr Fiona Cowell will explain the reasons if a change is recommended, and interventions go ahead with your informed consent. In a rare emergency, urgent decisions may need to be made quickly to keep you and your baby safe.

Can I have a vaginal birth after a caesarean (VBAC)?

Often, yes. After one uncomplicated caesarean, about 60 to 80 per cent of women who attempt VBAC give birth vaginally, according to the Royal Women’s Hospital. The main specific risk is scar rupture, about 4 to 5 in 1,000. Dr Fiona Cowell can talk through whether VBAC or a planned caesarean suits you.

When should I start talking about my birth options?

Birth planning is a conversation that can start early in pregnancy and continue at each visit. You can also raise it at your first appointment, or before you conceive if you have had a difficult birth or have a medical condition.

Book an appointment with Dr Fiona Cowell

Sage Women’s Specialists
55 Victoria Parade
Level 5, Suite 5
Fitzroy VIC 3065
Phone (03) 9415 6077 | Email hello@sagewomens.com.au. A GP referral is needed to claim the Medicare rebate.

Sources

This page provides general information only and is not a substitute for medical advice. Please see your GP or book a consultation with Dr Fiona Cowell about your own situation.